This content material comprises affiliate hyperlinks. When you purchase via these hyperlinks, we might earn an affiliate fee.
Until this fall I had, one way or the other, by no means truly learn A Christmas Carol. I’d seen films and listened to radio variations, however regardless of dwelling with a stunning version (belonging to my husband) for over 20 years, I’d by no means learn it. When I lastly sat down to take action, I found that it’s a nice deal greater than only a good story; Dickens’s prose is beautiful, the story strikes at a clip, it’s emotionally satisfying, and all of the variations of it that I used to be accustomed to and liked essentially the most borrowed liberally from the textual content, with no use to decorate it (past giving mentioned textual content to Gonzo) as a result of it was already good.
There have been many variations of A Christmas Carol, amongst them stage performs, films, and my favourite: radio dramas. Not to say all of the assorted audiobooks, many of them carried out as audio dramas. In truth, with so many choices, it may be tough to decide on a technique to devour this quintessential Christmas story.
The first stage manufacturing, A Christmas Carol: Or, the Miser’s Warning!, opened in February 1844, about two months after the novella was printed. Dickens continuously gave public readings, starting in 1853 with a studying of A Christmas Carol; over time, he tailored his personal novella to greatest go well with the format, and he continued to learn from it till his loss of life. To be sure, audiences within the nineteenth century didn’t have the choice to look at a film, however even at this time I discover listening to the story nice and a great way to spend a December night, with the xmas log burning on my TV (I dwell in SoCal, an actual fire can be too heat) and Chex Mix and cookies to snack on.
I’ve achieved the leg work that can assist you determine. I’ve listened to dozens of radio dramas, audiobooks, and different variations, and narrowed it all the way down to one of the best of one of the best.
A Note on Movie Adaptations of A Christmas Carol
There is little sense in rating film variations. The singular greatest model is The Muppet Christmas Carol, which is almost good in its theatrical model and completely good with the sometimes-missing “When Love is Gone” scene.) Beyond the Muppets, what model you watch relies upon fully in your style. (Of course, that is true for radio, too, however there are much more choices there.)
There’s the 2001 animated function, with the voices of Simon Callow, Nicolas Cage, and Kate Winslet. If you favor a modernization there’s Scrooged (1988), assuming you possibly can stand Bill Murray (some can, some can’t), or Rod Serling’s 1954 United Nations particular A Carol for Another Christmas, starring Sterling Hayden. Like musicals? There’s Scrooge (1970), starring Albert Finney. Ralph Richardson starred in a 1951 episode of Fireside Theater, whereas Alastair Sim starred in a theatrical function the identical 12 months. Guy Pearce took the lead in a 2019 model that leans all the best way into the gothic horror of the story.
Perhaps the strangest model is the 1978 TV film starring Rich Little in each function, doing an impression of a unique actor in every (he performs Scrooge as W.C. Fields and the Ghost of Christmas Past as Humphrey Bogart). For an alternate one-man model, BBC Films tailored Simon Callow’s stage play, which was primarily based on Dickens’s readings, in 2018.
The Best Audiobook Adaptations of A Christmas Carol
A Christmas Carol Narrated by Sir Patrick Stewart
This is THE gold customary audio recording. If you should select one audiobook, you’ll seemingly be pleased with this one. Sir Patrick Stewart reads with such pleasure and vigor that his voice veers sometimes into sounding extra like Michael York than Captain Picard, but it surely’s a delight.
This Audible Original is a must-listen in the event you love Tim Curry (present me the one who doesn’t; no, actually, I simply need to speak) but it surely lacks some of the depth present in different variations. Still, in the event you subscribe to Audible it’s value a hear.
A Christmas Carol Performed by a Full Cast Featuring Sir Derek Jacobi, Kenneth Cranham, Roger Allam, Brendan Coyle, Miriam Margolyes, Tim Mcinnerny, Jamie Glover, Emily Bruni, Jenna Coleman, Joshua James, and Hugh Skinner
Narrated by Sir Derek Jacobi as Charles Dickens himself and that includes a full solid, that is actually one of the best of each worlds, if these worlds be audiobooks and radio dramas.
A Christmas Carol Narrated by Jim Dale
I virtually didn’t embody this one, as it’s only obtainable on CD, but it surely’s simply too pleasant to understand it exists and never share it. You might know Jim Dale’s voice from Pushing Daisies or the British audiobooks of a sure boy wizard collection.
The Best Radio Drama Adaptations of A Christmas Carol
The majority of these can be found on varied audio companies corresponding to Spotify, and are additionally on YouTube; I’ve linked to movies when obtainable (most don’t have any visible element).
Campbell Playhouse Presents The Mercury Theatre (1938) Starring Orson Welles
Lionel Barrymore was slated to play the half however he was unwell and Mercury Theatre head Orson Welles took over and did double responsibility, performing his normal function of the narrator along with enjoying Scrooge. I don’t suppose I have to inform you how good Orson Welles is. This is the model I hear to each single 12 months, and it’s unparalleled.
Campbell Playhouse Presents The Mercury Theatre (1939) Starring Lionel Barrymore
Lionel Barrymore carried out A Christmas Carol yearly on CBS radio, beginning in 1934, with the exception of 1936 when his spouse died and his brother John Barrymore stuffed in, and 1938, when Orson Welles took over (see above). This 1939 recording, with Welles narrating, is a superb model; I additionally advocate his final trip, in 1953 for Hallmark Presents (sans Welles), however should warn you that his age is obvious in his voice (he was 75 years previous and died earlier than Christmas 1954).
Theatre Royal (1953) Starring Laurence Olivier
If you like Laurence Olivier, you’ll love this! Sir Larry narrates and performs Scrooge, and it’s a playful adaptation, if largely particular for the who quite than the what. (It can also be the shortest adaptation on this checklist, if time is a priority!)
BBC (1965) Starring Ralph Richardson
I actually like this model, and recognize the duality of Richardson as narrator and Scrooge. This drama takes its time and feels quite a bit like studying the ebook, which is an effective factor!
CBC Radio Mystery Theatre (1975) Starring Allan McFee
I haven’t discovered a lot details about this broadcast, but it surely appears to be one thing of a novelty, with Toronto Mayor David Crombie enjoying the function of Tiny Tim amongst an all-star(ish) solid that additionally included the Toronto Maple Leafs coach in a small function and narrated by tv persona Max Ferguson.
Green Space NYC (2015) Starring Kathleen Turner
This recording of the dwell efficiency is nice enjoyable and the one one I discovered that includes a lady as Scrooge. The present begins at about 5 minutes in, after a pleasant introduction for the dwell viewers. I actually benefit from the a number of narrator method!
Green Space had beforehand featured F. Murray Abraham (2011), Brian Cox (2012), Tony Roberts (2013) and Mark-Linn Baker (2014) as Scrooge.
Prefer books? How about these A Christmas Carol retellings? Or maybe you’d quite revisit the unique! Check out these quotes from A Christmas Carol, discover the names within the novel, or take a deep dive into the complexities of Tiny Tim. Want to department out to different Christmas tales? How about one of the best Christmas variations?